Heather by Caitlin Mullen

 A meticulous and atmospheric examination of a small town’s collective sins.

This was a haunting mystery that is set in the shadows of the New Jersey Pine Barrens. It takes place across dual timelines and is a slow burn noir that has a lot of deep emotional resonance. 

In the before: it’s 1990 and 16-year-old twins Annabelle and Sabrina Riley are seduced by an older man. Their father is often absent and their mother has vanished, so when they face a dire situation, no one really notices when both vanish without a trace. At the same time, a local girl delivering newspapers discovers a dead baby girl in the forest. 

Decades later, Callie Hauser returns to her hometown of Pine Lakes to serve as the new police chief. Her best friend, Jane Caputo, was severely injured in an accident and Callie wants to help Jane, her husband, Damien, and their small daughter as much as she can. 

Despite her own past and her messy situation with her mother, Jenna, Callie soon finds that her professional life and her personal life collide. A revelation by genealogical DNA forces Callie to face a legacy of family trauma that exposes the truth surrounding her own parents and uncovers the secrets tied to the disappearance of the twin sisters. 

Very well plotted with a slow unraveling of all the bits and pieces of the back story. I felt deeply for some of the characters whose life circumstances put them into such terrible situations with no one to help. I still don’t understand and was not happy about the legal charges but can’t say much due to possible spoilers. There were a few overwrought moments that veered into melodrama, but overall I enjoyed this book. 

I was able to listen to the audio book while also following along in the e-book ARC, both provided by the publishers via NetGalley. The three female narrators, Bailey Carr, Christine Lakin, and Mia Wurgaft, did an excellent job of voicing the main characters. Their dramatic flair was appropriate and created an immersive experience that enhanced my appreciation of the book. 

This is a standalone and is not part of any series.

Genre and tags: mystery, investigation, twin sisters, bad men, small town, bad parenting, drugs, murder, stillbirth, teen pregnancy, missing women, DNA, police